Affirmative Action
Essay Preview: Affirmative Action
Report this essay
I Have a Dream
Racial discrimination is a plague of the human mind, and has been important to the history of the United States, as well as continues to play a large role in current issues. But, it is rarely discussed how the majority is being subjected to racism every day. Affirmative Action is detrimental to the American Society because it creates discrimination, denies applicants that are well qualified, and harms the equal America that this country is trying to create.
In order to fully understand how Affirmative Action affectively ruins the chances of many well-qualified Americans each year, its process must be understood. Meet John. John is a senior in high school, and is also an average middle-class white male. John is busy in the process of applying to the university that has for long been a dream. Maybe its UW, UCLA, or even Stanford. After filling out applications, sending in FAFSA forms, getting letters of recommendation, and having English teachers correct entrance essays, John licks the envelope and sends off his application with hope for a positive answer in two months. The time quickly goes by, and each day is filled with anticipation each time the mail box is checked or the phone rings. One evening, the Dean of Admissions calls and breaks the news to John. Unfortunately, John has been denied application to the school. It came down to two students, and they had to give Johns spot to a Hispanic girl. John was qualified enough, in fact, more so than the other girl, but there is a quota that needed to be filled. While an applicant would never be told that Affirmative Action was the reason for denial, this is many times the kind of bias that is a result of Affirmative Action.
Affirmative Action was passed in the 1965 by Lyndon B. Johnson as executive order number 11246 (Murray, 193). At the time, it was intended to actively seek out blacks to help them get into schools and receive jobs. However, the 1960s was also the start of the biggest civil rights movements in our history. So as time went on, it was formatted to also include women, as well as all racial minorities. Any establishment that has a government contract must abide by Affirmative Actions law. Most commonly affected are public universities. There are two types of Affirmative Action. Weak action and strong action. Weak action is when a minority is given the upper hand by being favored in the application process. Standards are often even lowered for these people. For example, at the University of Michigan, you will receive 20 extra points on your application review just for being a minority (infoplease.com). Strong action is where an establishment has to fill a certain quota or ratio of minorities hired or admitted. This is also most common in public universities and large corporations, such as Boeing. Many times, a more qualified student or worker is turned down in order to meet these quotas, or sometimes out of sheer fear of being prosecuted for racial discrimination. This is why Affirmative Action is often referred to as “reverse racism” by its opponents.
When Affirmative Action affects universities, it extends to all areas of a school. One of the most famous cases for revealing Affirmative Action as racist was the famous Bakke case in 1978. Allan Bakke was a medical student who had been declined admission to the University of California, Davis medical school for two years in a row, and instead, less qualified applicants were granted admission. Davis had set aside sixteen spots out of one hundred to that could only be filled by racial minorities, a practice that is discrimination in itself (Infoplease.com). In 1973, those sixteen racial minorities that were admitted had an average overall GPA of 2.88, and an average science GPA of 2.62. Those not qualified for one of the sixteen reserved spots (white applicants) had an average overall GPA of 3.49 and science GPA of 3.51(ONeill, 29). And though this was over thirty years ago, some institutions are still practicing this type of discrimination. In 1997, there were 200 available seats in the UCLA Medical School for 5,000 applicants. 4,462 were either White or Asian. In this group, 142 were accepted. This is an acceptance rate of 3%. Amongst all of these, there was a combined average GPA of 3.8. Also included into consideration, were MCAT scores. The MCAT is the Medical College Admissions Test, and is graded out of a possible 15 points. The average score for Whites and Asians was 11.6. 538 applicants were put in the category of Black or Hispanic. 58 were accepted. This is an acceptance rate of 10.4%, over three times as much as the White and Asian group. In that group of Blacks and Hispanics, the average GPA was 3.42, with an average MCAT score of 9.8 (Murray, 201). Americans health care should not be taken into such trivial consideration.
A popular argument for those that support Affirmative Action is that minorities “deserve” this advantage as a correction of previous wrong doings by the majority. For years, America subjected racially minorities, largely blacks, to extreme hardships and prejudice, during the time that slavery was legal, and the years of racism that followed. Since a black persons ancestors perished, reparations should be reaped today. America owes it to those that it has hurt and discriminated against in the past. You can fix and make up for previous wrong doings by over-compensating now. Due to the psychological damage that these minorities endured, a fair playing field does not even exist in the mind, which in turn forces the minority to not have as much motivation to work hard and succeed.
If this were true, then does that mean that the Japanese should buy us new carrier ships and fighter planes for the ones that they destroyed during the bombing of Pearl Harbor? Does it mean that America needs to go back and replant all the vegetation that we destroyed during the Vietnam War? Should the Germans and/or the still existing Nazis pay back the Jews for destroying their homes and stealing their belongings during World War Two? The answer to all of these things is a definite “no”. The world is not a perfect place. And in terms of slavery, White people were slaves for thousands of years and long ago before blacks were treated like property. But you dont see the Romans or the Egyptians