Edgar Allen Poe
Essay Preview: Edgar Allen Poe
Report this essay
Everybody likes to read books or watch movies that make them think. An intriguing detective story will keep its readers on the edge of their seats. When reading these certain stories, one must wonder, “What was the first detective story?” and “Who wrote it?” The off-kilter Edgar Allen Poe was the first author of a detective story. In fact, Edgar Allen Poes detective stories, despite the harsh criticism they received, had a major influence on the forming of the detective genre and set the basic model of the detective story we know today.
How is a detective story unique and different from the average narrative? Willard Huntington Wright once explained a detective story effectively saying, “I believe the detective novel does not fall under the head of fiction in the ordinary sense, but belongs rather in the category of riddle; it is in fact, a complicated and extended puzzle cast in fictional form” (Wright 2). The detective story is in fact a puzzle, which the reader is forced to unravel. Detective stories are full of patterns. Creating patterns are what detective stories are about, Poe wanted to discover the patterns that were already there. Many of the detective story writers simply had to unravel the story themselves and put it back together for the readers to enjoy taking it back apart (May 83). Essentially, reading a detective story is like doing a cross-work puzzle.
Why did Poe write a detective story? What influenced him? Poes obsession with the idea of scientific experimentation influenced his thirst for an analytic story. His detective stories were analytical stories. They represented the ideas and problems that fascinated him (Wright 2). After a deep analysis of Poes detective story, one can see that Poe actually was projecting himself into the narrator. He, in fact, had some respect for Dupin, a character he created (May 92). He wanted to obviously make others feel the way he did about Dupin, thus he wrote the detective story. Poe has always been obsessed with the psychology of death and murder. R. J. C. Watt believed that Poes detective stories combine logic and an insight on the grotesque and the violent (Watt 1). All of the elements of Poes other stories are found in his detective story.
Edgar Allen Poe wrote many analytical stories, which are now considered detective stories. His four most famous stores are “The Murders in the Rue Morgue”, “The Mystery of Marie Roget”, “The Purloined Letter” and “The Gold Bug” (May 87). Poes first detective story was “The Murders in the Rue Morgue”, which he published in Grahams Magazine in April 1841 (Watt 1). In that story he introduced the first detective character ever written, C. Auguste Dupin. Poe didnt get immediate fame for his work. As a matter of fact, it took him two years, in 1843 to receive recognition for his detective story “The Gold Bug”. He even won a one hundred dollar prize for it, held by the Dollar Newspaper (Carlson 40). For the most part, however, Poes stories were well received by the public, but werent appreciated for being the first detective story; Mainly because this was a new type of story to be introduced at that time.
Many writers found a new angle at literature through Poes detective story. So much that he influenced many writers that we know today, such as Sir Arthur Conan Doyle or Agatha Christie. According to Willard Wright, “If we call Poe the father of detective fiction, Gaboriau was certainly its first influential tutor” (Wright 8). Gaboriau introduced the sleuth, Monsieur Lecoq. Many other authors realized there was an audience for the detective story. Many Authors like Anna Katharine Green, Doyle, and Christie took Poes original form to create detective stories. Many other characters were produced such as Sherlock Holmes and Detective Poirot.
All good detective stories are models of Poes original four detective stories, because of their psychological insight (Wright 7). All of the well-known detective stories we know today from The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes series right down to The Hardy Boys are all models of Poes original detective stories. Poe introduced the three-part structure of a detective story: introducing the penchant for mystification, the central even of mystification, and the resolution of the mystification (May 37). This is basically introducing the mystery, finding the clues to the mystery and solving the final mystery. Despite the complexity or length of a modern detective story, they all follow Poes original blueprint. Poe was also the first person to introduce cryptology part of the solution to a mystery. In fact Poe, made C. Augustine Dupin very well rounded in math and philosophy to make him outsmart the criminals easier (Wright 15). The character Dupin was even aware of this quoting, “The power of the robber results from the robbers knowledge of the losers knowledge of the robber” (Poe 4).
Some of Poes influences can be found directly in other detective stories. For example, the Narrator admires C. Auguste Dupin in “The Purloined Letter” the same way Mr. Watson admires Sherlock Holmes in all of the Sherlock Holmes stories. “I was enjoying the twofold luxury of meditation and meerschaum, in company with my friend C. Auguste Dupin” (Poe 1). There is obvious admiration in the tone of the narrator. Charles May commented, “The Narrator seems to admire Dupin, seeing him as a “double Dupin-