Political Systems of France and Britain
Essay Preview: Political Systems of France and Britain
Report this essay
COMPARITIVE POLITICS
SEMINAR II Ð- A DESCRIPTION OF TWO WESTERN EUROPEAN POLITICAL SYSTEMS
FRANCE AND GREAT BRITAIN
INTRODUCTION
I chose these two systems, which interest me for different reasons. The British system is one that has evolved over many centuries, with both small and large adjustments along the way to keep in on course. In contrast to this, the French model has changed dramatically on several occasions, and can rarely have been described as stable. However, in 1958 Charles de Gaulle made some brave changes to the constitution, which after being approved by the French public, set the scene for the classic semi-presidential system that we see today.
Despite these opposing histories, there are many similarities between the two systems, which I intend to discuss.
BRITAIN
The United Kingdom is a democratic constitutional monarchy, with a system of government often known as the Westminster Model. It has been used as a model of governance in many countries, and undoubtedly indirectly inspired many more.
Somewhat unusually, the constitution is unwritten, consisting of conventions along with statutory law and common law, which are collectively referred to as British constitutional law.
The head of state and theoretical source of executive and legislative power in the UK is the British monarch, currently Queen Elizabeth II. In theory, the British sovereign can dissolve Parliament whenever they desire. They can in theory choose any British citizen to be Prime Minister, even if they are not a member of the House of Commons or House of Lords. Theoretically, the Sovereign possesses the ability to refrain from granting Royal Assent to a Bill from Parliament, in addition to being able to declare war and appoint ministers.
In practice, the head of state is a largely ceremonial role, with powers restricted by convention. However, the monarch holds three essential rights, the right to be consulted, the right to advise and the right to warn. Also, as the position of head of state tends to be held for a longer period of time than that of Prime Minister, the monarch builds up lots of experience and wisdom which is at the disposal of the government.
Thus the political head of the UK is the Prime Minister(PM), who must be supported by the House of Commons.
The executive branch of the UK system is the Government (or more formally, Her Majestys Government). The monarch appoints (or in reality, approves) a Prime Minister, who in turn appoints other Members of Parliaments (MPs) to act as Ministers, who are collectively known as the Government, and head the various government departments. The cabinet is the most senior group of government ministers, and usually numbers around 20.
The Government is answerable to parliament, from which its members are taken. A vote of no confidence can be called if any government-sponsored bill is defeated in the Commons. If the vote of no confidence is passed, the PM must either resign, or ask the monarch to dissolve parliament, and call a general election. In practice, since a government usually holds a majority in the Commons, and party Ðwhips try to ensure that party members support the government, governments are likely to win all but the most controversial votes.
If however, a government doesnt have a large majority, then it will do it can to bring Ðbackbench MPs into line, and call three-line whips Ð- i.e. votes that are compulsory for MPs to attend, sometimes even being brought in from hospital beds to vote.
PARLIAMENT
The Parliament of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland is the supreme legislative institution in the United Kingdom and British overseas territories (it alone has parliamentary sovereignty). It consists of a head of state (currently Queen Elizabeth II), a bicameral system with an upper house Ð- House of Lords, and a lower house Ð- House of Commons
At its head is the Sovereign; it also includes an Upper House, called the House of Lords, and a Lower House, called the House of Commons. The House of Lords is an almost wholly appointed body. The House of Commons, on the other hand, is a democratically elected chamber. The House of Lords and the House of Commons meet in separate chambers in the Palace of Westminster (the Houses of Parliament), in central London.
The British Parliament is often called the “Mother of Parliaments,” as the legislative bodies of many nationsЖmost notably, those of the members of the CommonwealthЖare modelled on it. However, it is a misquotation of John Bright, who had actually remarked on 18 January 1865 that “England is the Mother of Parliaments”, in the context of supporting demands for expanded voting rights in a country which had pioneered Parliamentary government.
The differences between the constituent members of the UK are interesting, England, despite being the most developed, populous and richest member, is the only one without its own devolved government.
House of Commons
The UK is divided into parliamentary constituencies of broadly equal population (decided by the Boundaries Commission), each of which elects a Member of Parliament to the House of Commons. The leader of the party with the largest number of MPs is invited by the monarch to form a government, and becomes the Prime Minister. The leader of the second largest party becomes the Leader of the Opposition.
There is usually a majority in Parliament, thanks to the First Past the Post electoral system so coalitions are rare. The monarch normally asks a person commissioned to form a government simply whether it can survive in the House of Commons, something which minority governments can do, albeit with more problems than a majority government.
The House of Lords
The Lords has traditionally been the upper chamber, with a hereditary, aristocratic character. However, largely under Labour initiatives it has undergone dramatic reform, which is still in progress. There still remain some hereditary peers, but most are nowadays appointed peers. It holds powers to suggest amendments, and delay legislation, which mean that the Commons often seeks a compromise position to get a bill passed through the Lords.
Civil service
The civil service is a part