Discuss the Arguments That Antigone, Haemon and Creon Make on Either Side of the Debate. How Does the Writer, Sophocles Tell Us Who Is Right. – Essay – mphojanie
Search
Essays
Sign up
Sign in
Contact us
Tweet
Index
/English
Discuss the Arguments That Antigone, Haemon and Creon Make on Either Side of the Debate. How Does the Writer, Sophocles Tell Us Who Is Right.
This essay will be about the Sophocles’ Antigone. Antigone is a no-nonsense kind of woman and even when she first appears to us at the end of Oedipus the King, she was a no-nonsense little girl. Antigone, by Sophocles, is a story about the struggle between Antigone, who represents the laws of the gods and Creon, who represents the laws of the state. Antigone includes the several arguments on the rights of the individual versus the laws of the state and on the gods laws versus human laws. This essay will discuss the arguments that Antigone, Haemon and Creon make on either side of the debate. It will again tell us how the writer, Sophocles tell us who is right.
The conflict between Antigone and Creon was over which laws to respect. Antigone believed that some laws came from the gods. Such laws, such as the rites and rituals for proper burial, must be respected. In contrast, Theban King Creon believed that all lawmaking fell generally within the human domain, and most specifically within his powers as ruler of Thebes.
Antigone’s extreme loyalty is with the gods and their divine laws is what’s she holds more sacred. Antigone’s loyalty is once again on the full show when she announces that she will bury Polyneices regardless of the law of Creon. She is determined as she even said “I urge no more; nay, wet thou willing still, I will not welcome such a fellowship. Go thine own way, myself will bury him. How sweet to die in such employ, to rest sister and brother linked in love’s embrace a sinless sinner banned awhile on earth, but by the dead commended; and with them, I shall abide forever. As for thee, scorn, if thou wilt, the eternal laws of heaven” (p69-77). This is the disobedient performance and Antigone’s firm decision of loyalty to the remembrance of her brother that structures the basis of the play. Her persistent loyalty becomes her tragic error, her hamartia and eventually causes her downfall. Antigone is a prominent instance of how a hamartia does not certainly have to be a character “flaw” as it is frequently defined. Almost all people would name loyalty as a worthy attribute. Antigone’s dedication is so extreme, nevertheless, that it fetches misfortune once again to Thebes.
You most likely seen that “faithfulness” is a major word with regards to Antigone. Family dedication particularly is a major thing. She forfeits her own life for its sake. Her assurance is strong to the point that her character ends up emblematic of family dedication or blood ties. When we see her conflict with King Creon, it’s as though Sophocles is asking: “Who do we owe more unwaveringness to? The legislature or our families?” It’s not a hard inquiry for Antigone to reply, be that as it may, it probably won’t be as obvious as you might suspect.
Antigone’s argument is so very against the laws of the king, as she could not even care about the laws of man, as spoken to by Creon. At the point when these two resolute characters impact, the conflict isn’t only representative of government versus family; it’s additionally representative of man versus the divine beings.
All through the play, there are signs in the regular world that the divine beings are in favor of Antigone. For one, there are no impressions left adjacent to the body when Antigone first puts dust on Polyneices. Maybe the earth itself is endeavoring to help Antigone in her “wrongdoing.” When the Sentry reports this unusual wonder, the Chorus inquires as to whether it may be the divine beings’ work. The King expels the thought, saying the divine beings wouldn’t have any desire to help someone as awful as Polyneices.
We likewise observe divine help for Antigone, when the tempest seethes outside of Thebes. The Sentry and companions return to Polyneices’ body and wipe away the dirt that Antigone sprinkled there. No sooner do they do this than the residue emits from the earth and scratches out the sky. In the focal point of the tempest stands Antigone, crying for the divine beings to decimate whoever has re-tainted Polyneices’ body. Appears as though a reasonable sign that Creon would be advised to watch his back.
Antigone’s heavenly imagery is likewise observed when she is hauled before Creon soon after the Chorus’ acclaimed “Tribute to Man.” There’s additional on this in the Chorus’ “Character Analysis,” yet essentially the Chorus has quite recently completed singing a melody about how marvelous man is for vanquishing nature and how nobody should venture to our relentless laws. When they’re finished singing, Antigone is pulled in. It’s as though Antigone is the divine beings’ response to the Chorus’ overweening pride. She resembles a Fury, the divine beings’ apparatus for retribution.
Haemon’s argument is about her father Creon
Continue for 11 more pages »
Read full document
Download as (for upgraded members)
Citation Generator
MLA 7
CHICAGO
(2019, 04). Discuss the Arguments That Antigone, Haemon and Creon Make on Either Side of the Debate. How Does the Writer, Sophocles Tell Us Who Is Right.. EssaysForStudent.com. Retrieved 04, 2019, from
“Discuss the Arguments That Antigone, Haemon and Creon Make on Either Side of the Debate. How Does the Writer, Sophocles Tell Us Who Is Right.” EssaysForStudent.com. 04 2019. 2019. 04 2019 < "Discuss the Arguments That Antigone, Haemon and Creon Make on Either Side of the Debate. How Does the Writer, Sophocles Tell Us Who Is Right.." EssaysForStudent.com. EssaysForStudent.com, 04 2019. Web. 04 2019. < "Discuss the Arguments That Antigone, Haemon and Creon Make on Either Side of the Debate. How Does the Writer, Sophocles Tell Us Who Is Right.." EssaysForStudent.com. 04, 2019. Accessed 04, 2019. Essay Preview By: mphojanie Submitted: April 14, 2019 Essay Length: 2,850 Words / 12 Pages Paper type: Essay Views: 184 Report this essay Tweet Related Essays Discuss How You Would Go About Shaping a Response That an Animal Does Not Ordinarily Make. Identify the Animal and the Behaviour Clearly and Explain How You Will Go About Eliciting the Desired Response from the Animal. Learning Theory attempts to explain how an individual or organism learns. Learning can be achieved through observation, social facilitation, formal teaching, memory, mimicry, classical conditioning 337 Words  |  2 Pages Discuss the Way Gould Uses His Own Experiences to Make His Points 1.) Discuss the way Gould uses his own experiences to make his points. Writing about one’s own experiences is an effective method in conveying a 515 Words  |  3 Pages Antigone Vs. Creon "Morality is always the product of terror; its chains and strait-waistcoats are fashioned by those who dare not trust others, because they dare not trust 414 Words  |  2 Pages Clearly Define by Specific Traits the Character of Antigone and Creon Literature Portfolio QUESTIONS 1. - Clearly define by specific traits the character of Antigone and Creon. After her mother committed suicide, her father died 2,197 Words  |  9 Pages Similar Topics Maria Gaetana Agnesi Brief Discussion Antigone Study Moral Influences Society Get Access to 89,000+ Essays and Term Papers Join 209,000+ Other Students High Quality Essays and Documents Sign up © 2008–2020 EssaysForStudent.comFree Essays, Book Reports, Term Papers and Research Papers Essays Sign up Sign in Contact us Site Map Privacy Policy Terms of Service Facebook Twitter