Black Vernacular English From Virginia
Essay Preview: Black Vernacular English From Virginia
Report this essay
Black Vernacular English from Virginia
Black Vernacular English, a dialect at times used by as many as 80 to 90 percent of African Americans and long identified by whites as substandard English, is in fact a different and unique form of American English. Black Vernacular English (BVE), or Black English, is fundamentally a spoken language derived from the slaves and still remarkably consistent throughout African American culture. Because of the roots and many unique aspects of Black Vernacular English, it qualifies as a unique form of American English just as other regional dialects, such as Southern English or Yankee English.
Black English is remarkably similar in structure across many geographic boundaries in the United States. Spoken BVE in Florida is virtually identical to spoken BVE in Washington State. This lends credence to the argument pointing to a common origin for the language. However, where is that location? Many linguists and scholars point to African tribal language for the origins of Black English, proposing that some of the sentence structure and verb conjugations are similar to those used by tribes in Western Africa or to Gullah, as spoken in the West Indies and Caribbean nations. However, Dr. Walter E. Williams, syndicated columnist and chairman of the Department of Economics at George Mason University, points out the error in that assumption in his 1995 article for Social Science Quarterly. He writes:
“Yawl might axin me why I be writin dis way. Yawl might tink ma fambly didnt gib me a gud upbringin. Yawl might say Ah be a no-count, woebegone yaller dawg fit for nothin but taters and chittlins. What be wrong wid yo innards and book learning, Yawl might be axing?
Run that paragraph by your intellectual multiculturist at one of our universities. Ask him to comment on the language or dialect. Five will get you ten hell perk up and say, Why thats Black English; Id know it anywhere! But it taint. It is as white of an English as you can get.”
Further evidence that Black English is derivative of that spoken by the slaves in the southern United States can be found in David H. Fischers book, Albion Seed. He writes that in 1773, Philip Fithian, from New Jersey, went to Richmond, Virginia to teach. In his journal, he told how Northerners said, “I am,” “You are,” “She isnt,” and “I havent,” whereas Virginians, “even if high rank,” preferred to say “I be,” “You be,” “She aint,” and “I haint.” They also had a way of softening consonants: sebem for seven, chimbly for chimney, mo for more and wid for with. These Virginia speech patterns were not invented in America. They came to America from regional dialects spoken in southwest England during the 17th century. Fischer says, “In the twentieth century, words like “dis” or “dat” were rarely heard in any part of rural England, but they persisted among poor whites and blacks in the American South.” Since the African American population was nearly 100% concentrated in the early southern colonies, it makes sense that BVE is the same across the culture. The diversity of location in todays African American population shows a migration outward from the Old South. We must then conclude that most assumptions about Black English