Essay About Classical Chinese Poetry And Edward Said

Arts of the Contact Zone
Essay Preview: Arts of the Contact Zone
Report this essay
Lost in Translation or Gained in Creation:
Classical Chinese Poetry Re-Created as English Poetry1
Roslyn Joy Ricci
Centre for Asian Studies
University of Adelaide
Introduction
The well-known Robert Frost2 witticism that poetry is what disappears in translation
is only valid if poetic translation aims to produce a perfect re-creation of the original,3
however, I suggest that successful translators re-create poetry in another language as opposed
to translating it into a second language.4 The aim of re-creating poetry is to attempt to produce
the same reader-response as the original poem did. This generic formula holds true in the
specific case of Chinese poetry re-created as English poetry. I use the term re-created for
poetic translation because literal translation of poetry struggles to produce the same reader
response as the original poem does.
1 This paper was presented at the 15th Biennial Conference of the Asian Studies Association of
Australia in Canberra 29th June-2 July 2004. It has been peer-reviewed and appears on the Conference
Proceedings website by permission of the author who retains copyright. The paper will be
downloaded for fair use under the Copyright Act (1954), its later amendments and other relevant
legislation.
2 American poet Robert Frost (1874-1963).
3 James JY Liu, The Poetry of Li Shang-yin, 1969, p. 34.
4 Yan Fu (1853-1921) set the standard for translation from a modern Chinese perspective: primarily
xмn (faithfulness), then d* (fluency) and finally y* elegant). Elegance must give way to fluency and
fluency to faithfulness.
This paper explores the challenges to, and strengths of, classical Chinese poetry recreated
as English poetry as a transcultural poetry integral to a world poetic critique as
proposed by Stephen Owen. It examines issues of contextualisation, critical theories, notions
of Otherness and the possibility of world poetry along with Owens reply to my reading of
his thesis.
During the latter half of the twentieth-century, the trend of presenting poems in the light of
critical theory and within their historical context continued to dominate the genre of classical
Chinese poetry re-created as English poetry. Both Chinese and Western critical theories were
used, sometimes jointly and at other times in isolation. However, the application of Western
critical theories to re-created Chinese poetry is problematic because it imposes the values of
Western discourse on an artistic product of the East. So, what are the consequences of using a
Western theoretical paradigm to critique classical Chinese poetry?
Theoretical Paradigms
Edward Saids 1978 seminal text, Orientalism,5 warns scholars about a structure of cultural
domination6 that interprets Eastern cultures7 through a Western paradigm. One might well
argue, however, that Saids use of a Western critical framework to express this concern still
favours hegemonic Western interests. Moreover, Said fails to acknowledge the extent to
which Asian intellectuals contribute to conceptual and practical Orientalism.8 Nevertheless,
omissions by Said9 do not rule out the existence of a structural imbalance. Accepting the
imposts of orientalism, how can the dilemma be addressed?
Said suggests that the work of the critical scholar is to find the connections between Eastern
and Western struggles over historical and social meaning, despite differences.10 This idea is
developed by postcolonial theorist Arif Dirlik. He suggests producing discourse that escapes
the burden of Orientalism by recasting historical, cultural and political relationships in the
context of contemporary thought – providing new theoretical departures in literary and
5 Edward Said, Orientalism, 1978.
6 Ibid, p. 25.
7 Ibid, pp. 202/203: The Orient that appears in Orientalism, then, is a system of representations framed
by a set of forces that brought the orient into Western learning, Western consciousness, and later,
Western Empire Orientalism is a school of interpretation whose material happens to be the Orient,
its civilizations, peoples and localities.
8 Said 1978, p. 105.
9 Arif Dirlik, Chinese History and the Question of Orientalism, History and Theory, vol. 35, issue 4,
1996, pp. 96-119.
10 Edward Said, Orientalism: Afterward dated 1994, 1995, p. 332.
cultural criticism.11 Dirlik suggests that contact zones, as coined by Mary Louise Pratt,
prove useful12 in conceptualising the space in which