The Cask Of Amontillado
Essay Preview: The Cask Of Amontillado
Report this essay
Edgar Allen Poes “The Cask of Amontillado,” is a story of revenge to the highest degree. This theme is evident in the first sentence, “the thousand injuries of Fortunato I had borne as I best could, but when he ventured upon insult, I vowed revenge.” The suggestion of vengeance is repeated several more times in the opening paragraph. Poe gives us a view at premeditated murder from the details in his story told through the eyes of Montresor. While he carefully removes unnecessary parts of the story, Poe elaborately and vividly relates this bone-chilling tale of revenge while keeping his audience waiting for more. The theme of Poes “The Cask of Amontillado” is reprisal and he uses all the elements of fiction (plot, setting, characters, and theme) in illustrating this theme to his readers.
In the beginning of the “The Cask of Amontillado,” the reader learns that Fortunato has insulted the main character and narrator of the story, whose name, Montresor, we do not learn until the very end of story. However, we purposely are never told just how Montresor was offended by Fortunato. Montresor states that he “must not only punish, but punish with impunity.” Montresor wants revenge for Forunatos wrongdoing, but he does not want to be punished for what he will do to Fortunato. Montresors innate desire causes him to thoroughly plan for his former friends murder, but he is sensible and desires that his deeds will not damage him or his reputation. This is mainly because Montresor believes he is fully justified in killing Fortunato for his insults and thus should not be punished for what he believes is doing the right thing.
It is clear from the very first paragraph that what Montresor has planned for Fortunato is horrific, but justified death. Montresor states “A wrong is unredressed when retribution overtakes its redresser. It is equally unredressed when the avenger fails to make himself felt as such to him who has done the wrong.” This line explains how Montresor feels about revenge, that it is necessary for him to kill Fortunato for the insult.
The setting of Edgar Allen Poes “The Cask of Amontillado” is also very important in telling of the story. The tale first takes place in the evening during the carnival season. Fortunato enters the story, presumably intoxicated from enjoying the festivities a little too much, and therefore, according to Montresor, offers him a warm greeting. The story soon changes when Montresor takes Fortunato to his dark and mysterious crypt fueling an atmosphere saturated in evil. Montresor has planned for his reprisal to be enacted during the carnival season for several reasons. Not only due to the disguises that people wear, but also because it allows for him to have an excuse for his servants not being in the house. This is important because their absences would otherwise alert Fortunato to something being not quite right. Furthermore, Montresor knows that his friend while be drinking and that in light of the festivities, Fortunato will not turn down more and more alcohol. Montresor is planning on Fortunato being drunk for his plan to work in the way that he has intended.
Soon after the first scene at the carnival, Montresor leads Fortunato down to his catacombs to taste his Amontillado, which he believes to be counterfeit. While down in the catacombs, Fortunato remarks that the catacombs are quite extensive, then Montresor replies that his family was “a great numerous family.” Fortunato asks about his coat of arms, to which Montresor replies “Nemo me impune lacessit” or no one assails me with impunity. Montresor obviously lives by this motto as seen by the actions that he takes for Fortunatos insults.
Poe uses a great deal of ironic elements in his writings and this is especially true in “The Cask of Amontillado.” Even when naming his characters, Poe creates names that are satirical. In Italian fortunato means fortunate, which Fortunato clearly is from reading the story. It is likely that Fortunato comes from a good family who has a great deal of wealth, which is why he is a connoisseur of Amontillado, a rare and expensive sherry. Perhaps Poe derived the name Montresor from the word monster, which after reading the story many would agree Montresor is indeed. In addition, Montresor mentions Luchesi, an acquaintance of both the men. Montresor claims that he was going to have Luchesi taste Amontillado, because he knows that Fortunato will be outraged by this and insist on trying it himself. Fortunato does not believe that Luchesi is as good of an expert as he himself is. Poe uses the name Luchesi, which is derived from the Italian word lucrative.
Irony is used in the beginning scene of Poes “The Cask of Amontillado.” When we first meet Fortunato he is dressed as a jester. According to the story, “he had on a tight-fitting parti-striped dress, and his head was surmounted by the conical cap and bells.” This is an important part of the story, because we know that Montresor wishes for revenge and wants Fortunato to feel like a clown as he felt when Fortunato had insulted him.
Ironic language is also used in “The Cask of Amontillado.” When Fortunato first volunteers to try the Amontillado, Montresor claims that he worries about his friends severe cough and that going into the damp, cold catacombs will not be good for his health. But Fortunato insists, as Montresor has counted on him doing. Later, while being led through the catacombs, Fortunato begins to cough. Montresor tells him that they should go back so as to not tip Fortunato off to what he is about to do. Again, just as Montresor has planned, Fortunato says, “enoughthe cough is a mere nothing; it will not kill me. I shall not die of a cough.” To this Montresor replies, “true–true,” for he knows exactly what Fortunato will be dying from very shortly.
An additional example of irony used in the dialogue between the characters deals with masonry. While in the catacombs, Fortunato makes a gesture at Montresor, but he does not understand what it means. Fortunato makes the gesture again and when he sees that Montresor still does not understand, he says, “Then you are not of the brotherhood.” Montresor questions how, to which Fortunato replies, “You are not of the masons.” Montresor insists he is, but Fortunato does not believe him and asks him for a sign. Montresor holds up his trowel (a tool used by masons), but Fortunato believes his friend to be joking, since