Ancient Astronauts
Essay Preview: Ancient Astronauts
Report this essay
Ancient Astronauts
The basic story/argument being presented is the notion that aliens are responsible for the most ancient civilizations on earth. Erich von Daniken claims that the myths, arts, social organizations of ancient cultures were introduced by astronauts from another world. He questions not just the capacity for memory, but the capacity for culture and civilization itself, in ancient people. Prehistoric humans did not develop their own arts and technologies, but rather were taught art and science by visitors from outer space.
DanikenĂ²Ăââ˘s evidence is in the form of specious and fallacious arguments. His data consists mainly of archaeological sites and ancient myths. He beings with the ancient astronaut assumption and then forces all data to fit the idea. For example, in Nazca, Peru, he explains giant animal drawings in the desert as an ancient alien airport. The likelihood that these drawings related to the natives religion or science is not considered. He also frequently reverts to false dilemma reasoning of the following type: “Either this data is to be explained by assuming these primitive idiots did this themselves or we must accept the more plausible notion that they got help from extremely advanced peoples who must have come from other planets where such technologies as anti-gravity devices had been invented.”
Where is the proof for von DÔ¤nikens claims? Some of it was fraudulent. For example, he produced photographs of pottery that he claimed had been found in an archaeological dig. The pottery depicts flying saucers and was said to have been dated from Biblical times. However, investigators from Nova (the fine public-television science program) found the potter who had made the allegedly ancient pots. They confronted von DÔ¤niken with evidence of his fraud. His reply was that his deception was justified because some people would only believe if they saw proof.
There have been many critics of von DÔ¤nikens notions, but Ronald Story stands out as the most thorough. Most critics of von DÔ¤nikens theory point out that prehistoric peoples were not the helpless, incompetent, forgetful savages he makes them out to be. (They must have at least been intelligent enough to understand the language and teachings of their celestial instructors–no small feat!) It is true that we still do not know how the ancients accomplished some of their more astounding physical and technological feats. We still wonder how the ancient Egyptians