Mechanisms of Control
Essay Preview: Mechanisms of Control
Report this essay
Mechanisms of Control
In George Orwells 1984, the strategies used by Oceanias “Party” to achieve total control over the population are similar to the ones emplaced by Joseph Stalin during his reign. Indeed, the tactics used by Oceanias “Party” truly depicts the brutal totalitarian society of Stalins Russia. In making a connection between Stalins Russia and Big Brothers Oceania, each party implements a psychological and physical manipulation over society by controlling the information and the language with the help of technology.
In fact, many features of Orwells imaginary super-state Oceania are ironic translations from Stalins Russia. In Oceania, the “Party” mainly uses technology as the chief ingredient to implement a psychological manipulation over society by controlling the information they receive. An example of this is the big screen television set up in every persons home, and the poster all over the city. The giant “telescreen” in every citizens room blasts a constant stream of propaganda designed to make the failures and short successes of the Party appear to be glorious. In Winston Smiths apartment, this “instrument” is always on spouting propaganda and constantly brain washing the peoples mind. In actual fact, “It could [only be] dimmed there [is] no way of shutting it off”. In doing this, the “Party” is in complete control over the citizens mind, blasting
Salazar 2
what they want each individual to think (p.6). They psychologically stimulate each individuals mind, limiting their ability to think and have a mind of their own. In a similar way, Stalins created “The Poster” and The Pravda (the Russian newspaper controlled by the government during Joseph Stalins regime) to twist and manipulate the minds of people into believing that what they were saying was absolutely right and truth. Using this power, Stalin and his regime would get people to do anything for them. (Basgen, Soviet History- website)
The creation of gigantic posters is one of the most psychological manipulating tactics used in Oceania and Russia with the enhancement and help of technology. In Oceania, one could find “A colored poster…with the face of a man… [Whose] eyes fallowed you about when you moved”. The caption in the poster says that “Big Brother Is Watching You” (p.5). In placing poster like these all over Oceania, people are constrained and restricted to their actions. They are in a constant battle all the time debating whether their actions are right or wrong in the eyes of “Big Brother”. For example, when Winston sits down to write in his dairy, he writes “in sheer panic, only perfectly aware of what he was setting down” (p.11). In this instance, Winston is afraid of the act of writing in a dairy, but he decides to do so in sheer panic. This results as the effect of Oceanias “Party” psychological manipulation of the mind. Every time a person decides to do something, they will have a sheer image of the poster and the caption “Big Brother Is Watching You” in the back of their heads. Hence, this action limits the person capability to act freely and express their inner sentiments. (Jeffrey p.220-225)
Salazar 3
Alike, “The Poster” was the most prominent form of psychological manipulation during Stalins reign. Until World War I the poster had avoided social themes. However, as Stalins Russia rose to war and as a world power, the posters took a turn to be commercial and cultural, an attempt to develop an expanding market and advertise various entertainments. The posters of World War II took on a new task: to mobilize the population in support of the war effort. Stalins Posters featured themes of mobilizing the armed forces, reconstructing the economy, as well as various specific war time problems. It was at this point that the government began to make efforts to “shape public opinion” and “arouse patriotic feelings”. The government assigned this task to the mass media. Every political event in Russia found resonance in a poster.
The main Communist Party newspaper, Pravda, announced the issuing of each new poster, political or economic. Publishing information about the posters promoted the style of art among broad masses of Russia. In addition to announcing the new publication of a poster, Pravda would issue a review of the poster. Posters became such an important tool for propaganda, that the words, “Those who take down the poster commit a counter revolution”, were printed at the bottom of each poster. Thus, “With the help of this handiwork in the streets and in the squares, the rapprochement between art and the people that other dreamers have been waiting for will come about. It is not pictures hanging in museums, or book illustrations passed among book lovers, or frescoes, which are accessible only to the few, but the poster and the lubok (Russian folk print), which are produced in the millions for the masses and the streets that will bring out to the people, show them what can be done and with brush and paint, intrigue them
Salazar 4
by their artistry and unleash the pent up reserves of artistic possibilities” (Viacheslav Polanski). In doing this, Stalin and his regime manipulated and brained washed the individuals of their society just like the “Party” did in 1984. With these tactics, the people are only told what the political party wants them to hear (Jeffrey p.240-5).
In addition to psychologically manipulating the peoples mind, the “Party” and Stalins regime physically manipulate society through the control of language and technology. “The Party” in 1984 keeps citizens under surveillance through the telescreens. They are found in all rooms belonging to Party members as discussed earlier, and in public places. No one knows how often the Thought Police tap into any individual wire. “It [is] conceivable that they watch everybody all the time (p6). As a result, people are always with a fear of behaving the wrong way and try to act and say the “correct” things the government wants. They are physically manipulated. Lets