The Giver Reflection
The Giver Reflection
Im not really sure how to start analyzing this one, but it seems to me that it is not until the very end of the text that the author begins to get to the point–although Im honestly not sure what that is or how to relate it back to our theme of evil and suffering. But, either way, here goes:
Something that really caught my attention was The Misfits comments with regard to Jesus and the grandmothers insistence that he learn to pray since that seems directly related to religious studies. It isnt until the grandmothers life is in danger and she is coming face-to-face with evil and suffering that she begins preaching the virtues of prayer, prompting The Misfits remark: “She would of been a good woman if it had been somebody there to shoot her every minute of her life.” I suppose this reinforces something our group discussed in class. We concluded that evil and suffering was universal (in this case, the evil appears to be The Misfits persecution of random innocents). We also discussed that when confronted with evil and/or suffering, religion is frequently turned to. I think we can see this working in two ways in OConnors A Good Man is Hard to Find.
First of all, we look at the grandmother. She begins preaching about prayer and Jesus in hopes that she will strike some kind of emotional heartstring to make The Misfit reconsider his actions. We can assume that she is only doing this in order to protect her life and that she likely wouldnt have given the same sermon to someone she wasnt trying to sway. She wasnt preaching in hopes of salvaging The Misfits tarnished soul; she was doing it for herself. She was using religion solely as a tool for her own purposes.
On the other end of the spectrum is The Misfit. He speaks in length about his life, mentioning what “good” people his parents were. At the same time, however, he tells the grandmother: “Nome, I aint a good man” so it could be proposed that on some level he views himself as some embodiment of evil. The Misfit tells the grandmother he knows Jesus would help him, but that he doesnt want Jesuss help. He later compares himself to Jesus. He says the only difference is that Jesus was punished without having committed a crime, while he was punished for his crime (though unfittingly, he explains). But what I suppose fits in best with our theme of religious responses to evil suffering comes just before The Misfit shoots the grandmother. He says it wasnt fair that he wasnt there when Jesus lived because he couldnt know if Jesus really raised the dead. He says, “if I had of been there I would of known and I wouldnt be like I am now”. Presuming that we perceive The Misfit as evil incarnate in some way, we can look at his religious response to his own evilness. That response seems to be one of anger. That statement leads us to believe that he blames Jesus for his evil and suffering.