Essay About Process Politicians And Government Agency

Ians Decision
Join now to read essay Ians Decision
When evaluating Ian’s dilemma regarding the illegal cover up of overbilling, fraudulent contracts and
illegal awarding of funds, it is apparent he is confronted with a multitude of ethical issues. However, his
position requires he take the proper steps in ensuring his agency and its employee partake in the ethical
behaviors that are for the good of the country and its citizens. It is evident the government agency is
involved in the practice of fraud, corruption, misappropriation of government funds and war
profiteering. It is Mr. Stalwart’s duty to reveal this cover up, although the agency has attempted to
appeal to his emotions and implement a straw man fallacy it is nothing more than an attempt to further
conceal the already apparent illegal acts. Since the effort has been made to silence Mr. Stalwart there
are several options of action he can take to resolve the central issue. Appealing to someone within the
government who his outside of the agency and whose ethical principles and position differ from those
involved would be a logical choice, he also could anonymously provide a tip to a higher authority within
the agency thus following the chain of command, however, if an attempt is made to silence his
discoveries the wisest and ultimate option would be to contact the media with his findings. Remaining
silent and refusing to reveal the truth would further jeopardize the institution of government, future
politicians, the military, The United States and its citizens, other countries, those involved in the illegal
activity and Mr. Stalwart himself.
The United States and its government over the past several years have lost any credibility amongst other
nations do to these sorts of misconducts and strong arm mentalities. Many people have lost faith in
their government, and the world has been confronted with a multitude of violence towards their fellow
man and in the process politicians believe there is no consequence to their actions or decisions. Perhaps
this is due in part to similar unethical situations that Mr. Stalwart is now confronted with. These acts are
a direct representation of war profiteering, those involved line their pockets with government funds,
while thousands of young women and men are losing their lives. These greedy and unethical practices
and the politicians who partake in them jeopardize their said constituents, the economy, the integrity of
our nation and the future safety of our world. It’s apparent this agency has forgotten the purpose of
government, which is “for the people by the people” , these scenarios and stakeholders are what Mr.
Stalwart needs to consider when deciding his plan of action.
In identifying and applying the ethical principle to this issue, Mr. Stalwart could theorize and apply
several, For example: “Act Utilitarianism” maintains that the right thing to do in any situation would be
to take action which produces the greatest possible good for the greatest number. He could also apply
“Rule Utilitarianism” in his decision process; this theory maintains the right thing to do is follow the
moral rule that would produce the greatest possible good. Thirdly, the theory of “Natural Rights” is
justified and relevant to the issue because it emphasizes exclusive protection of and reliance upon basic
human rights, its principle duty is to avoid violating the rights of others.
According to Immanuel Kant, he believed “we don’t have to rely on authorities to tell us what is right or
wrong we can figure it out for ourselves” This theory could be interpreted from two different
perspectives