Essay About Westphalian State And Warner

The Westphalian Model in Africa – Research Paper – Rebecca Bramley
Search
Essays
Sign up
Sign in
Contact us
Tweet
Index
/Social Issues
The Westphalian Model in Africa
The Westphalian Model In Africa
Introduction
The Westphalian model of statehood the world currently subscribes to has affected representations of Africa and Africa’s place in the International Relations field. This essay will explore the extent to which Africa has been affected by the Westphalian model. It will do this by first looking at sovereign statehood which comes along with the Westphalian model and theories that describes this. It will then look at Africa’s place in the international sphere historically and what models of statehood Africa had before colonisation as well as how Sovereign statehood was imposed on Africa as a result of colonisation. Lastly it will look at Africa’s status in the international sphere currently and how Africa is represented in the world today.

Sovereign statehood.
“The Westphalian state was the product of centuries of development and change,
it was a social construct, not an historic God-given instrument of social, economic and political organisation and it was the product of a specific era and context. As such then, one should be alerted to the possibility of change and difference – time passes and institutions and meanings attached to institutions change.” (Schoeman, 1997, 3) Schoeman suggests in the above that the state is socially constructed and thus its definition is subject to change, indeed a state by modern definition may differ from pervious definition of the state. The modern definition of a state is a specific territory with a defined population with legitimate source of violence invested in the government. Space is divided politically. (Schoeman 1997, 3)

Realists argue that a state is a community in an anarchic international system and this community must be able to defend itself from enemies and the non-self. (Warner 2001, 66) For realists a state is defined by its ability to maintain itself in the international community. Some realist theorists argue that a state is based primarily on the legitimate or organised violence of the government. Thus the state must define itself above other institutions as the primary source of legitimate violence which allows the state to control the population in the territory. (Warner 2001, 67) From this one can deduct that from a realist perspective territory is an important part of statehood; whether it is the ability to defend the territory or the ability to control its population.

On the other side of the scale there are Constructivists. Constructivists argue that there are many states who do not meet the requirements to be a state but yet are still considered states as a result of the state claiming that they are in fact a state on behalf of the people in that state. (Warner 2001, 68) Weber argues that a state comes about when “the action of various individuals is oriented to the belief that it exists or should exist” (Weber 1995, 78) This shows that from the constructivist school states do not necessarily have to meet the definition of a state but rather have to socially construct themselves as a state to become a state. In the African context constructivist would suggest that “the development of the state system in Africa has been dependent on actors defining, while using the terms and concepts of sovereign statehood, who they are and what they want.” (Warner, 2001, 69)

Institutionalists are of the view that state come into being partly as a result of being recognised by states that are “like them”. (Warner, 2001, 69) Warner states that Institutionalists and Constructivists both take from each other view and have some similarities in their outlook on statehood but adds that these views are also part of mainstream IR and thus have looked at Africa and tried to mould it into the Westphalian state system even though there were other political state systems in place simultaneously. (2001, 69)

Pre-colonial Africa.
Pre-colonial Africa had many different forms of political communities but it is unclear if any of these would be considered a state within the definitions mentioned above. To look at these political communities and try to determine if they are a ‘state’ clearly has a western bias attached to it, one is trying to make African political communities fit the mould of the Westphalian state model. (Warner, 2001, 69) Indeed, the terms given to these political communities are western and thus make it difficult to determine what type community was really in place.

Islamic political communities are one example of the various types political communities in Africa. For Islamic political communities territory was not the main priority rather it was a secondary concern. Warner discusses these polities in some detail and she

Continue for 8 more pages »
Read full document
Download as (for upgraded members)
Citation Generator
MLA 7
CHICAGO
(2016, 11). The Westphalian Model in Africa. EssaysForStudent.com. Retrieved 11, 2016, from
“The Westphalian Model in Africa” EssaysForStudent.com. 11 2016. 2016. 11 2016 < "The Westphalian Model in Africa." EssaysForStudent.com. EssaysForStudent.com, 11 2016. Web. 11 2016. < "The Westphalian Model in Africa." EssaysForStudent.com. 11, 2016. Accessed 11, 2016. Essay Preview By: Rebecca Bramley Submitted: November 23, 2016 Essay Length: 2,182 Words / 9 Pages Paper type: Research Paper Views: 460 Report this essay Tweet Related Essays 1920's Flappers - Good Role Models? In the 1920's many women were known as flappers. Flappers were not the best role models for younger girls. They were teenage girls who dared 410 Words  |  2 Pages The Campaign for North Africa The Campaign for North Africa: The Battle of El Alamein ranks both "Strategically and psychologically, as a decisive battle of World War II. It initiated 2,454 Words  |  10 Pages Commerce with Africa INTRODUCTION Africa in july 2005 is composed approximately by 887 millions people living in 54 different states. Africa is the world’s poorest inhabited continent, and 3,043 Words  |  13 Pages Motives for British Imperialism in Africa Motives for British Imperialism in Africa Before the Europeans began the New Imperialism in Africa, very little was known about the inner parts of the 5,649 Words  |  23 Pages Similar Topics Porters Profit Vrio Model East Africa Long Distance Trade Get Access to 89,000+ Essays and Term Papers Join 209,000+ Other Students High Quality Essays and Documents Sign up © 2008–2020 EssaysForStudent.comFree Essays, Book Reports, Term Papers and Research Papers Essays Sign up Sign in Contact us Site Map Privacy Policy Terms of Service Facebook Twitter